Alright I recognize your position Ali but Azeris began speaking Turkic language after the 12th century (perfectly As outlined by some sources and me) then untill the twelfth century there was no contribution to Azeri literture?
Nizami In spite of being a Sunni, praises Ferdowsi and it has proven which side he normally takes in that dispute and so does the Shirvanshah.
When poets mention Turk,India, Rome, Ethiopia one must acquire thing to consider of symbolic condition of your poets emotion from the context. When genuine characters are in Perform, then that is different (as an example Khaghan of Turks).
اي ترك، به گنجه از كجا افتادي كاندر دل و جان من، فكندي شادي
1) The ethnicity of Nizami's father. This is rarely recognized for one hundred% and there is no unanamious consideration. In truth I certaintly feel via the evidence I brought Nizami was ethnic Iranic and Mr. Baguirov would like to pressure an interpretation of a particular verse, which isn't supported from the previous and new English translations and also the symbolism is apparent as I have demonstrated earlier mentioned (see the Rumi, Khaghani, Attar quotations).
When the later definition results in being distinct then there won’t be any dispute on quite a few of these difficulties. But when I see some Azeri paper check with Shahnameh to be a international Tale (Inspite of three of Nezami’s tales staying straight from the Shahname and he menioning Kawa many instances) and embrace KorOghlu fully, then I'm dismayed. I've also seen some examples the place Azerbaijani republic people also usually do not regard Iranian nationality and also Assess it to soviet identification and say Safavids didn't generate an Iranian id While a state by definition makes a countrywide identification (American id Irrespective of 1000s of ethnic teams) and therefore an Iranian nationwide identity at the least existed from Safavid period.
Owning learned, that in numbers of stars there is really like/attachment, in place of the insidiousness, For the arrived he has chose to hand around his empire.
Iledigizd is a superb time period also. For the reason that conditions [twenty] Atabakan-e Fars; Atabakan-e Lorestan; Atabakan-e Maraga; Atabakan-e Yazd,  does not likely denote a modern point out strategy plus the borders of these states contained components of varied regions plus they were underneath the control of Seljuqids (often nominally and at times more). Such as Maragheh is cnsidered as Azerbaijan by Pretty much all sources nonetheless it was not managed by Illdegizid. But here is my instructed Variation which I believe will satisfy Mardavich too and it really is correct.
شده چون خانه زنبور با غم از ترکان // همی خلند به فرمان ما چو زنبورم (همان ؛ ص۱۹۷)
حدثنا الحسين بن عمرو الأرديلي عن واقد الأرديلي عن مشايخ أدركهم أن المغيرة بن شعبة قدم الكوفة والياً من قبل عمر بن الخطاب، ومعه كتاب إلى حذيفة بن اليمان بولاية أذربيجان. فأنقذه إليه وهو بنهاوند أو بقربها. فسار حتى go to this site أتى أردبيل، وهي مدينة أذربيجان وبها مرزبانها، وإليه جباية خراجها. وكان المرزبان قد جمع إليه المقاتلة من أهل باجرون وميمذ والنرير وسراة والشيز والميانج وغيرهم.
Also lets remember that Nizami takes advantage of the phrase Tork-zaad(a term used in classical Persian poetry this means a son of Iranian who experienced a Turkic wife) for his son from his wife that was presented to him from the ruler of Darband.
Have a tough consider the substance of such beliefs, and stay away from ways of persuasion that don't respect the dignity and liberty with the human human being.
The difficulty is usually that Tajiks look at on their own Iranic persons, so there's no contradiction. In case the persons of Azerbaijani republic considered themselves Iranic as opposed to Turkic, then I would have no dilemma too. Note if Azarbaijani's of your republic of Azerbaijan didn't overlook their Iranian, Median and Zoroastrian heritage and did not blindly simply call them selves Turks (it can be such as the Irish who communicate English calling themselves Anglo-saxon), I wouldn't even have a difficulty.
This can be an archive of earlier conversations. Usually do Visit This Link not edit the contents of this web page. If you want to begin a fresh discussion or revive an aged one, remember to achieve this on The existing speak web site.